Score: 10

"as ever wow"

submission: the YuYu

date: November 10, 2007

Doesn't matter how many times I watch this movie, it still blows me away every time!
Everything about it is absolutely brilliant, the illustration, the animation, the music, the cinematography etc.
You even have the sweat evaporating off Bitey's arms at the end. What can I saw!

Oh there is one thing I can say. Who the hell are these people that don't give this movie or indeed all the Brackenwood episodes full marks? I mean seriously how can this submission have an average score of 4.27! what's the mater with these people!

Score: 3

"It's a nice idea"

submission: Everything has changed

date: October 16, 2007

Having just this tranquil scene. Makes for a change from the normal all action packed submissions.
To be honest I don't think it works because the visuals just aren't arresting enough.
It could be a lush movie though, if u were to really really invest in the fine details, like the way u have the guys heir blowing in the wind.
So for example, maybe, Animate a very slightly change the sky colour,
Have the vegetation also moving in d wind,
Give the stars a bit of a twinkle
Perhaps ever have the camera view move a little
U get the idea.
Actually I feel quite inspired to have a go myself now!
Anyway hope that was constructive. Its good to see someone trying something a bit different.

Score: 7

"It certainly was random"

submission: R-r-r-random

date: October 10, 2007

I liked it though . very well animated.
U really should give your movies thumbnail images when u submit them though. I'm sure I'm not alone in normally boycotting submission which don't have thumbnails, on the assumption that, if someone hasn't done one, it's because the content is so bad that it might put people off watching it.
Which obviously isn't the case here.
Anyway good stuff keep it up.

Score: 7

"i liked it"

submission: Cyanide & Happiness fan

date: October 3, 2007

Short and sweet, good stuff!

Score: 10

"I'm speechless"

submission: TANKMEN 2

date: September 28, 2007

So I'll spear u the critique and just say that was just f*£!ing wicked!

Score: 5

"Ah the simple pleasures"

submission: The Dead End Collab

date: September 13, 2007

If nothing else, the mouse chaser was really entertaining :)

Score: 8

"My sentiments exactly"

submission: CD- SAW 2

date: September 6, 2007

Why don't they take the f***ing hint and stop or make an unreserved apology for their dreadful work and then stop.

cool movie by the way

Score: 5

"Space slugs have potential!"

submission: Space Slug Episode1

date: September 4, 2007

Space slugs, limited u say! I've really got to disagree.
Check out "Captain Star- Ned Nova" on YouTube or something, if u don't beleave me.

Score: 7

"refreshing to see something a bit different"

submission: Compact Discs

date: September 3, 2007

Nice idea and refreshing to see something a bit different.
The best bits were u animated the camera as well as the disks.
I thought at one point the disks were going to form a line and lead the cam around the room a bit. something like that, just to get the camera moving , & changing angles would make it that much more interesting I think. That is if yu thinking of doing sequel.

Any way good stuff

Score: 0

"Do everything completely different next time"

submission: Another Bloody M23 Short

date: September 1, 2007

Ok u want constructive criticism, here u go:
*Do everything completely different next time.

*Practice drawing so u can illustrate it better.

*Likewise practice animating so u can animate it better.

*DO NOT use that irritating synthesized voice, tat reeks of the "clock crew" and everything dreadful that they represents.

*If the movie has to be 10sec or less, then at least make it a funny one-liner.

*Finely do not use misleading thumbnails which suggest the movie might actually be better than it is.